Councillors share concerns over reorganisation process

-

Concern has been shared that the new unitary authorities planned to be created after existing councils are abolished will not last 10 years.

Councillors at Cambridgeshire County Council raised concerns about the local government reorganisation process and questioned whether it would deliver the benefits hoped for, at a meeting last week. 

Under local government reorganisation, the councils in Cambridgeshire could cease to exist by 2028.

Instead, they would be replaced by new unitary authorities that would provide all the services currently split between district councils and the county council.

The Government asked all the councils in the area to develop a new council structure, in the hope that fewer, larger councils would help save money.

New structure

Initially, three options were announced as the main proposals being considered in Cambridgeshire.

The first proposal (Option A) could involve the creation of two unitary councils: one encompassing Peterborough, Huntingdonshire, and Fenland, and the other comprising Cambridge, East Cambridgeshire, and South Cambridgeshire.

The second proposal (Option B) could also involve the creation of two unitary councils, one encompassing Peterborough, East Cambridgeshire, Fenland, and Huntingdonshire, and the other comprising Cambridge and South Cambridgeshire.

The third proposal (Option C) could involve the creation of two unitary councils: one encompassing Peterborough, East Cambridgeshire, and Fenland, and the other comprising Cambridge, Huntingdonshire, and South Cambridgeshire.

However, further proposals were later put forward, including a ‘Greater Peterborough’ option suggested by Peterborough City Council, and a proposal for a standalone Huntingdonshire unitary council put forward by Huntingdonshire District Council.

The deadline for submitting proposals for the future council structure to Central Government is November 28.

‘Very short timescales’

New Shire Hall, the headquarters of Cambridgeshire County Council. Credit: LDR Service

At the county council meeting on 21 October, a majority of councillors agreed that the authority should make a case to the Government to consider Option A.

Councillor Lucy Nethsingha (Liberal Democrat) said local government reorganisation had been “forced” on the area and that the process set out by the Government offered “very short timescales and very restrictive criteria”.

She said she was “pleased” the County Council would be submitting Option A to the Government to consider, as she believed it was the “best available option” for the area.

Councillor Alex Beckett (Liberal Democrat) said the area had been “rushed” into reorganisation as the Government was “trying to save money rather than trying to do the right thing”.

He said the Government had put a process in place with rules they had to follow and argued not putting an option forward would be a “disservice” to the area.

Doubts over boundaries

However, others raised concerns that East Cambridgeshire was not the only part of the wider county with links to Cambridge.

Some councillors pointed out that people living in towns and villages in Huntingdonshire also had links with the city.

Councillor Alex Bulat (Labour) said there was a lack of support in Huntingdonshire for Option A and said she could not justify voting for something that had “such low public support” in the area she represented.

Councillor Sarah Caine (Liberal Democrat) said the process put forward by the Government was “deeply flawed”.

She said having to base the new authority boundaries on existing Council boundaries did not “reflect the reality of people’s lives”, highlighting two villages in her area of Huntingdonshire that could be placed in separate unitary authorities.

Cllr Caine said she would support the recommendation to submit Option A for the Government’s consideration, but proposed an amendment to highlight the concerns about the process they had to follow.

Scepticism 

Councillors debated the issue at length on October 21, 2025. Credit: LDR Service

Questions were also raised at the meeting about whether reorganisation would be successful and whether the County Council should be engaging with it at all.

Councillor Chris Boden (Conservative) said local government reform had always been a “nightmare for Governments” in the past when it had been attempted.

He questioned whether the new council system, whatever it is, will last as long as the existing council structures have.

He said: “It is a very difficult process, which is why in the past this process has not been rushed; this is a rushed process.

“I have to say I do not think the results we will get out of this local government rearrangement, if it goes ahead, I’m not confident it will last 50 or 60 years, I think in 10 years the system will fall apart and we will have to be reorganised again.”

Councillor Steve Tierney (Conservative) said councils did have another option and could choose not to comply with the process.

He said: “When the Government says we must comply, we say no we do not comply, no options, go away and leave us alone, we are doing fine.”

Option A questioned

Councillor Peter Rees (Green Party) said the meeting had heard from councillors about how they did not agree with the process and it was “awful”, but that they had to vote in favour of the recommendation before them to submit Option A.

However, he said he did not accept that and said they needed to stand up for themselves and “vote truthfully” on what councillors believed was in the best interest of people in the county.

Councillor Elisa Meschini (Labour) criticised the Liberal Democrat amendment to the recommendation and argued if the administration did not think the process offered the best option, they could not have taken part.

She also said if the administration did not believe Option A offered the best boundaries, they could have instructed officers to work on something else.

Cllr Meschini said they could have looked at moving existing council boundaries and that other areas in the country had done this.

Concerns noted

Councillor Ricky Ioannides (Reform UK) said he had concerns about the proposal to “wave through” Option A without a full independent business case.

He added that he did not support local government reorganisation in principle.

He said: “Bigger does not automatically mean better. Without hard evidence, it usually means it is further from residents and dearer for taxpayers.”

South Cambridgeshire District Council is supporting Option B. Photo: SCDC

Councillor Tom Hawker-Dawson (Liberal Democrat) said agreeing to submit Option A was not about what they preferred, but about what the Government should be asked to consider.

He said he believed they should look at “all credible options” and that Option A needed to “stay on the table”.

Councillor Robin Wyatt (Liberal Democrat) argued the timescales set out by the Government did not give Councils enough time to look at options that would change the existing council boundaries.

A majority of councillors ultimately agreed that the authority should submit Option A to the Government to consider, with the amendment to highlight concerns about the local government reorganisation process.

Other options

Meanwhile, South Cambridgeshire District Council and Cambridge City Council are supporting Option B. 

This will be debated at upcoming Council meetings, before the Councils submit their own proposal to Central Government for the November deadline. 

Reporting by Hannah Brown of the Local Democracy Reporting Service.

READ MORE: Devolution process begins for Cambridgeshire, Councils say more time is needed to explore devolution and Councils at odds over local government shake-up

Popular Posts

Selected Directory Listings